May 30, 2009

In which I impart actual useful information

I asked some of the amazing people I've met at the Prentke Romich Company if they could point me to studies actually illustrating that AAC use contributes to overall language and/or speech development, not just providing a voice but actually aiding in the development of other communication methods, including verbal. I should have known they would come through. One of the things I love about PRC is that the people who represent them in the field aren't sales representatives. They are SLPs and therapists, they are the same people who fight our monsters and they do so with real weapons, the ones they believe in.

And when it comes to AAC and its implementation, they know their stuff.

Anyway, here are some direct quotes from the book Exemplary Practices for Beginning Communicators: Implications for AAC by Joe Reichle, David Beukelman, and Janice Light. I'll have more to share soon.

(There are also some further resources listed at the end, so you can... Read More About It!)

-----

1.) "Although some existing research literature and recommended practices data support the notions that even very young children and other beginning communicators can use and benefit from AAC (e.g., Pierce, 1999; Romski & Sevcik, 1996), some professionals still believe that AAC is a last resort to be tried only after all other interventions have failed and the individual is still not talking (Romski, Sevcik, & Forrest, 2001). This belief may contribute to why AAC is often not incorporated into prelinguistic intervention strategies. Typically developing children primarily rely on gestures to communicate until about 12-13 months of age, when they increasingly use speech for communication (Goldin-Meadow, 2000). Using a developmental perspective, AAC interventions (e.g., gestures, devices, switches) can be viewed as tools to develop prelinguistic skills and set the stage for later vocabulary development regardless of whether the individual eventually talks."

2.) "Previously, it was assumed that individuals need to demonstrate the prerequisites of sensorimotor stage V for sufficient symbolic understanding to begin to learn how to use AAC (e.g., Chapman & Miller, 1980; Owens & House, 1984). It was later recognized that individuals can acquire some of the presumed prerequisite skills much earlier through the functional use of AAC in naturalistic environments (Kangas & Lloyd, 1988; Reichle & Karlan, 1985)."

(Quote specific to speech output devices:)

3.) "Romski and Sevcik (1996) argued that the use of a speech-output communication device was a critical component of their participants' successful use of SAL (System for Augmenting Language). They contended that the speech output provided a link to the natural auditory world for participants. Yet, no direct comparison of SAL acquisition (speech+symbols) with learning symbols alone was provided. Schlosser, Belfiore, Nigam, and Blischak (1995) conducted a study on three individuals with severe mental retardation who would have been considered beginning communicators. The researchers compared the participants' acquisition of visual graphic symbols and speech output with the acquisition of visual graphic symbols alone. They found that the speech output + visual graphic symbols resulted in more efficient learning with fewer errors than the visual graphic symbols alone. These results support Romski and Sevcik's argument that speech output can play a critical role in AAC language learning."

-----

Pierce, P. (1999). Baby Power: A guide for families using assistive technology with their infants and toddlers. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.

Romski, M.A. & Sevcik, R.A. (1996). Breaking the speech barrier: Language development through augmented means. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.

Romski, M.A., Sevcik, R.A., & Forrest, S. (2001). Augmentative and alternative communication in inclusive early childhood programs. In M.J. Guarlnick (Ed.), Early childhood inclusion: focus on change (pp. 465-479). Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.

Goldin-Meadow, S. (2000). Beyond words: The importance of gesture to researchers and learners. Child Development, 71, 231-239.

Kangas, K.A. & Lloyd, L.L. (1988). Early cognitive skills as prerequisites to augmentative and alternative communication use: What are we waiting for? Augmentative and Alternative Communication, 4, 211-221.

Reichle, J. & Karlan, G. (1985). The selection of an augmentative system in communication intervention: A critique of decision rules. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 10, 146-156.

Schlosser, R., Belfiore, M.A., Adamson, L.B. (1995). The effects of speech output technology in the learning of graphic symbols. Journal of Applied Behavioral Analysis, 28, 537-549.

8 comments:

Karen said...

Hmmm. Where quote #1 doesn't really provide evidence of AAC helping nonverbal kids become verbal, quote #2 ("It was later recognized that individuals can acquire some of the presumed prerequisite skills much earlier through the functional use of AAC in naturalistic environments.") is a good indicator of it helping in other areas, and quote #3 shows real promise. Since the study it references was only composed of 3 severely mentally retarded individuals, it's not really enough evidence to make it cut and dry, but it's a good indicator that AAC's at the very least don't harm future interventions, thus negating Dr. Leaf's concern. I'd love to see a much larger study done.

MS said...

The Handbook of Augmentative and Alternative Communication would a good place to look--Denise DeCoste is one of the authors. Janice Light has a book as well, which I can't recall the title of, but I don't own it. My AAC class in grad school used the first book I named... Might want to check to see if there is an updated version; mine has to be 10 years old by now.
Also, research done by Karen Erickson and David Koppenhaver will give you information on AAC & literacy (writing & reading).

Samuel Sennott said...

I have been working on my response for a couple days now and am very excited about the conversation that has started. Linking AAC and speech in a total communication system is an important topic to discuss. I am glad we all feel so passionate about it and how it relates to those we serve. Here is my response: http://www.alltogetherwecan.com/2009/05/30/aac-and-speech-are-all-parts-of-a-total-communication-system-that-is-fully-individualized-for-the-particular-individual-it-serves/

There are three key additional references listed there as well.

little.birdy said...

I've got a whole bunch of articles on the subject because I wrote a paper about this and made a poster and did other vaguely scholarly things. I can send them along, if you like. :)

Samuel Sennott said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Samuel Sennott said...

Binger, C., Berens, J., Kent-Walsh, J., & Taylor, S. (2008). The effects of aided AAC interventions on AAC use, speech, and symbolic gestures. Seminars in Speech and Language, 29(2), 101-11. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1079124.
-

Schlosser, R. W., & Wendt, O. (2008). Effects of Augmentative and Alternative Communication Intervention on Speech Production in Children With Autism: A Systematic Review. Am J Speech Lang Pathol, 17(3), 212-230. doi: 10.1044/1058-0360(2008/021).
-
Millar, D. C., Light, J. C., & Schlosser, R. W. (2006). The Impact of Augmentative and Alternative Communication Intervention on the Speech Production of Individuals With Developmental Disabilities: A Research Review. J Speech Lang Hear Res, 49(2), 248-264. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2006/021).

Elizabeth said...

Great stuff to add to the arsenal. I only ask, "why does this all have to be so hard?" Meaning, it's hard enough to battle the actual monster and then the legion, too...

Rebecca said...

Rob, I have to say that because of reading you book and blog, it has lead us to PRC. We are looking at the new-not yet out on the market-ECO-14 with ECOpoint for my daughter with Rett Syndrome. We are excited about this new device, as I hear the theme organization is the easiest to learn! Thanks for making me more aware of the AAC options out there!